MLB Rumors: The Toronto Blue Jays Need a Backup Plan for Max Scherzer
It didn’t take long for one of the Toronto Blue Jays’ biggest offseason acquisitions to hit a snag. In his Blue Jays debut, veteran star and future Hall of Fame pitcher Max Scherzer exited after just three innings due to lat soreness. Shortly after, he landed on the 15-day IL with right thumb inflammation—a lingering issue that has now evolved into a major concern. Scherzer himself has admitted that his thumb and lat problems are connected, and while the team remains hopeful for a quick return, uncertainty looms.
With both Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette set to become free agents after this season, 2025 is Toronto’s last guaranteed opportunity to make a deep playoff push with their two franchise cornerstones. This is not the season to take unnecessary risks, and the Blue Jays must act swiftly to secure a viable replacement for Scherzer.
The Blue Jays Must Find a Reliable Stopgap
Currently, Toronto is scrambling to fill Scherzer’s spot in the rotation, believing they may only need two temporary starters. However, given Scherzer’s age and his ongoing health issues, it would be wise to have a long-term contingency plan. Fortunately, there’s one high-upside arm still available on the free-agent market.
Spencer Turnbull: A Perfect Low-Risk, High-Reward Option
Former Tigers and Phillies starter Spencer Turnbull remains unsigned, despite boasting impressive numbers. Last season, Turnbull pitched 54.1 innings with a stellar 2.65 ERA and 58 strikeouts. His breaking ball metrics ranked among the best in baseball, largely thanks to his newly developed sweeper. Turnbull even made history in 2021 by throwing a no-hitter against the Mariners, showcasing his immense potential.
So why is he still available?
Like Scherzer, Turnbull has struggled with injuries. Over the past five years, he has been limited to just 192 innings, including missing the entire 2022 season. While his durability is a concern, the upside is undeniable. More importantly, due to his injury history, he could be acquired at a bargain price—a low-risk, high-reward proposition that makes perfect sense for a Blue Jays team in win-now mode.
Why the Blue Jays Can’t Afford to Hesitate
With the AL East as competitive as ever, Toronto cannot afford to wait and hope Scherzer makes a quick recovery. A proactive move to sign Turnbull would provide much-needed insurance and help stabilize the rotation.
If the Blue Jays are serious about contending in 2025, now is the time to act. Signing Turnbull could be the under-the-radar move that helps Toronto stay in the hunt for a championship, ensuring they make the most of their final season with Guerrero Jr. and Bichette leading the charge.
Add a comment