MLB Rumors: Cardinals’ Nolan Arenado Trade Talks Heat Up, But Red Sox Move in a Different Direction
The St. Louis Cardinals are reportedly exploring trade options for star third baseman Nolan Arenado, but his hefty contract and full no-trade clause complicate the process. Initially, the Boston Red Sox appeared to be the frontrunners—until they made a surprising pivot by signing Alex Bregman instead.
Nolan Arenado’s Trade Market and Contract Challenges
The Cardinals have been actively shopping Arenado for months as they transition into what appears to be a retooling phase. However, moving him is no easy feat. Arenado has more than $50 million remaining on his contract and the ability to veto any trade, making negotiations particularly challenging.
Reports indicate that Arenado has pre-approved potential deals to the Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Angels, Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Mets, San Diego Padres, and Philadelphia Phillies. However, no trade has materialized yet.
Despite the ongoing trade speculation, the Cardinals have started the season strong with a 3-0 record, and Arenado is performing at an elite level. Through 11 at-bats, he’s slashing .455/.538/.909 with a home run and two doubles—proving that he remains a top-tier offensive force.
Red Sox Passed on Arenado for Alex Bregman
According to Bob Nightengale of USA Today, the Red Sox were deep in trade talks with St. Louis and were on the verge of acquiring Arenado before a major shift in their plans.
“The Boston Red Sox were deep into trade talks and on the verge of acquiring Nolan Arenado from the St. Louis Cardinals until Alex Bregman dropped into their laps,” Nightengale reported.
While this might sting for Cardinals fans, there’s a silver lining. Arenado’s hot start only increases his trade value, meaning St. Louis could command an even better return package if they move him later in the season. While trading him earlier may have allowed the Cardinals to integrate a younger third baseman and acquire immediate assets, his current production makes him an even more attractive trade chip.
Why This Works for Both Sides
For the Red Sox, the decision to sign Bregman instead of trading for Arenado made perfect sense. By landing Bregman in free agency, Boston retained its top prospects and avoided surrendering valuable trade assets.
Meanwhile, for the Cardinals, keeping Arenado—at least for now—positions them to maximize his trade value. If he continues performing at this level, St. Louis will be in a prime position to negotiate a stronger deal when the time is right. In the end, this situation may work out favorably for both teams.
Add a comment